The autonomous car trap in terms of eliminating traffic jams
My list

Author | Marcos Martínez

Autonomous mobility presents notable advantages compared to manual driving. It will be more efficient calculating both the best route and the range of speeds, but also safer, given that, thanks to Car 2 Car communications, part of the Internet of Things, the information collected by a car will reach the community to perfect its performance. However, this type of system is a far cry from being the panacea to urban and peri-urban mobility proclaimed by its developers. In fact, however efficient they may be,autonomous vehicles will not resolve the problem of traffic jams.

Understanding how traffic jams happen

Although all traffic jams consist of vehicles backing up to a standstill, not all traffic jams have the same origin. We can define two different types:

Bottleneck traffic jam. An excessive number of vehicles try to access a much narrower road than the current one. For example, going from a 3-lane motorway to one with two lanes.

The phantom traffic jam. Curiously, this does not require a bottleneck or high density traffic. It occurs when a vehicle gets so close to the one in front of it that it has to brake suddenly, transferring that same effect on to the vehicles behind.

https://youtu.be/Rryu85BtALM

The avoidable phantom traffic jam

In 2008, the researcher Yuki Sugiyama illustrated that this type of traffic jam by using dozens of cars in a closed circuit. His experiment “bottleneck traffic jam”, blames an impatient driver for the jam. Is there a solution?

Yes, and it stems from keeping a safe distance. If you can’t, another way of preventing it would be to position the vehicle we are driving halfway between the car in front and the one behind. In 2016, William Beatty, with the help of the Wall Street Journal, illustrated how a single driver, following these rules, could prevent the formation of traffic jams.

Years later (2018), a team of researchers headed by Raphael E. Stern proved that a single autonomous vehicle would have a positive effect and would prevent phantom traffic jams, as predicted a little earlier, in 2016. The evidence is very visual.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MtwY9xKfaYo

The bottleneck effect cannot be avoided

On the other hand, we have the bottleneck effect generated because of too many vehicles trying to access a road, which they don’t fit on at a moderate speed. It is true that autonomous solutions such as those illustrated above would help with traffic issues, and also autonomous carsharing vehicles with a higher occupancy would prevent between 50% and 75% of vehicles. But, even so, there would be traffic jams. Why?

We have viewed bottleneck traffic jams as a balance of drivers prepared to wait in a holdup. If a lane was added, there would not be many jams for weeks. This has been the strategy in many cities. However, this situation would soon be inverted.

New drivers that used to use public transport, seeing that it doesn’t take long by car, decide to drive. Despite the additional lane, their gradual arrival soon leads to traffic jams like those seen before, dissuading future drivers from doing the same thing.

The same happens if a lane is removed: for weeks there will be monumental traffic jams, but gradually many drivers will choose public transport until an equilibrium is reached. The result is the Nash Equilibrium, which claims that everyonewill do what best suits them.

Is there a solution for traffic jams?

Unfortunately, the answer to that question is categorically no. Roads such as the Katy Freeway (USA) have proved that its 26 lanes do not solve the traffic problem: if more lanes are added, more drivers will arrive. But, if they are eliminated, people will start to use public transport.

Which is why cities such as Copenhagen, San Francisco, Bogota or Hanoi have chosen urban lanes and to increase pedestrianisation. Traffic jams will still exist, but they will be less intense.

Images | iStock/Olga Kurbatova

Related Content
3 most important predictions for mobility and smart cities in 2021
3 most important predictions for mobility and smart cities in 2021
Paris is turning its iconic street into pedestrian gardens
Paris is turning its iconic street into pedestrian gardens
Too Many Companies Are Banking on Carbon Capture to Reach Net Zero
Too Many Companies Are Banking on Carbon Capture to Reach Net Zero
Greener air travel will depend on these emerging technologies
Greener air travel will depend on these emerging technologies
Tech show offers transport solutions for COVID-changed world
Tech show offers transport solutions for COVID-changed world
Which cities are the best for those without a car?
Which cities are the best for those without a car?
7 mobility startups to watch in 2021
7 mobility startups to watch in 2021
Pedestrianizing cities: Yes, but with alternatives
Pedestrianizing cities: Yes, but with alternatives
Urban mobility will center on MaaS, driverless delivery: report
Urban mobility will center on MaaS, driverless delivery: report
The future of cities is walkable, healthy, resilient places
The future of cities is walkable, healthy, resilient places
The technology changing the way we drive
The technology changing the way we drive
Boundaries of Smart Mobility
Boundaries of Smart Mobility
How high-end cameras and algorithms are making escooters safer
How high-end cameras and algorithms are making escooters safer
Shaking up the African mobility arena
Shaking up the African mobility arena
Micromobility could replace 51% of Chicago car trips
Micromobility could replace 51% of Chicago car trips
More working from home will transport us back to the future
More working from home will transport us back to the future
California clears Nuro's driverless cars to start making commercial deliveries
California clears Nuro's driverless cars to start making commercial deliveries
CIT-UPC: Innovation and Technological Solutions in mobility, health and flood alarm systems
CIT-UPC: Innovation and Technological Solutions in mobility, health and flood alarm systems
German start-up Volocopter to launch flying taxis in Singapore in next 3 years
German start-up Volocopter to launch flying taxis in Singapore in next 3 years
Smart transportation roundup
Smart transportation roundup
Self-driving robotaxis are taking off in China
Self-driving robotaxis are taking off in China
Ride-Sharing Giant Cabify to Track and Offset Carbon Emissions Using Blockchain Platform
Ride-Sharing Giant Cabify to Track and Offset Carbon Emissions Using Blockchain Platform
CRRC: Coupler system
CRRC: Coupler system
CRRC: Intelligent operation and maintenance of railway vehicles
CRRC: Intelligent operation and maintenance of railway vehicles
CRRC: OLED interactive window
CRRC: OLED interactive window
CRRC: TACS- Revolutionary Technology for Train Operation control
CRRC: TACS- Revolutionary Technology for Train Operation control
What can other cities learn from Madrid Central’s mistakes
What can other cities learn from Madrid Central’s mistakes
D2D3: AllInCarto
D2D3: AllInCarto
dots.: Future Intelligent Transportation Systems
dots.: Future Intelligent Transportation Systems
Positium: Public transport planning with Mobile Positioning Data
Positium: Public transport planning with Mobile Positioning Data
NaviLens - the next generation QR code for a smart and inclusive mobility
NaviLens - the next generation QR code for a smart and inclusive mobility
Meep: An app that integrate all available modes of transport
Meep: An app that integrate all available modes of transport
Wallbox Chargers: QUASAR
Wallbox Chargers: QUASAR
Eurecat: NasApp
Eurecat: NasApp
DigaliX Solutions: Interactive Tourism App
DigaliX Solutions: Interactive Tourism App
Cloudics: Solutions for fueling stations that can be operated from the cloud-based web manager, by Astro Baltics
Cloudics: Solutions for fueling stations that can be operated from the cloud-based web manager, by Astro Baltics
The Post-pandemic Transformation of Urban Mobility
The Post-pandemic Transformation of Urban Mobility
Unicard: Multimodal transport made easy
Unicard: Multimodal transport made easy
Passenger: Enabling transport innovation
Passenger: Enabling transport innovation
Smart City and Region Energy: Sizing up the energy transition
Smart City and Region Energy: Sizing up the energy transition
Cyclomedia: Streets speak out smart
Cyclomedia: Streets speak out smart
2030 Agenda and Urban Agenda for Catalonia: from Strategy into Practice
2030 Agenda and Urban Agenda for Catalonia: from Strategy into Practice
“Honk more, wait more”. Mumbai tests anti-toot traffic lights to curb noise pollution and jams
“Honk more, wait more”. Mumbai tests anti-toot traffic lights to curb noise pollution and jams
Mexico City: a successful approach to public transportation
Mexico City: a successful approach to public transportation
Latest news and innovations in autonomous driving
Latest news and innovations in autonomous driving
Janette Sadik-Khan, former NYC Transportation Commissioner: Freedom is about being able to go anywhere without having to use a car
Janette Sadik-Khan, former NYC Transportation Commissioner: Freedom is about being able to go anywhere without having to use a car
This is how electric vehicle charging points can be integrated into the urban architecture
This is how electric vehicle charging points can be integrated into the urban architecture
A global dilemma: will hydrogen be the fuel of the future?
A global dilemma: will hydrogen be the fuel of the future?
From driverless trams to automated depots: Germany robotises its public transport
From driverless trams to automated depots: Germany robotises its public transport
Car manufacturers are aware that the future is bleak
Car manufacturers are aware that the future is bleak
Recommended profiles for you
gf
gerard franco
FIRA BARCELONA
SALES EXECUTIVE MANAGER
Tarun Mathur
Tarun Mathur
Tarun Mathur, Structural Consultant
Owner
WT
Waldir Tume
Municipalidad de Miraflores
Gerente
Jose Serrano
Jose Serrano
Catalonia Exponential
Innovation manager at ACCIÓ - Catalonia Exponential, Government of Catalonia
Macello Medeiros
Macello Medeiros
Inpatics
Co-founder
JF
Julio Fernández Bernal
Ayuntamiento de Elche
Education and Road Safety Coordinator
AC
Andre Campbell
Building Future Cities
Consultant
AY
Ana Yuritzi Gonzalez Yuri
Un grito de paz
Planning\\n
Álvaro Andrade
Álvaro Andrade
ALSA
HEAD OF INNOVATION
GP
Gustaf Patrikson
Voi Technology
CSO
Ekaterina Uzunova
Ekaterina Uzunova
Breda University of Applied Sciences
Researcher and Project Management Assistant
DT
Daisuke Terada
Axis Comminications
Country Manager
MS
Marchos Saarepera
SKYCORP OÜ
I am a mechatronics engineer. I find new solutions and develop them for my company.
CA
Carlos Almeida
EVIO - Electrical Mobility
CEO
BEAL BEAL
BEAL BEAL
MECAPOLE
Sales Manager - We provide Mechanical sub assemblies or primary parts upon customers specifications
PR
Peter Rødbro
carmuterpass.com
Founder
Bartomeu Alorda
Bartomeu Alorda
Universitat de les Illes Balears
Associated professor
HM
Hernan Meneses
Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira
Researcher in Urban mobility
Av
Art van Dut
It 4 You
U
Ersan GURDOGAN
Ersan GURDOGAN
PITON
Funding and Grant Manager

Only accessible for registered users
This content is available only for registered users
TO: $$toName$$
SUBJECT: Message from $$fromName$$