This article is available also in spanish here

Over-planning and the risk of creating less inclusive cities

My list

Author | Tania Alonso

In an increasingly technological world, millions of people lack the training required to adapt to digitalisation. Furthermore, public administrations and private companies focus their efforts on creating smart cities that foster economic growth, without taking into account the possible creation of elements of inequality.

The UNESCO estimates that around 192 million unemployed people are not equipped to find work in an increasingly dynamic labour market. Which involves simple skills such as reading, writing and arithmetic, but also, digitalisation. These figures illustrate the need to design models in which priority is given to social inclusion. And above all, which respect the quality of life of citizens.

More than half the world’s population already lives in urban areas

“Urbanisation has been one of the most significant driving forces of recent global development”, according to the World Bank. Cities currently account for approximately 80% of GDP generated worldwide And they are home to more than half the world’s population.

Smart cities are a solution for organising and optimising life in cities. However, creating inclusive cities remains a challenge. In fact, some of the harshest criticism directed against urban planning in new cities is related to gentrification and social exclusion.Behind this criticism lies the idea that the changes favour those less in need. That is, those with strong purchasing power, a high level of education and access to the digital world. Very often they do not provide any benefits for people at risk of exclusion and limited purchasing power. The elderly population is a good example.

The risk of gentrification

Gentrification is one of the risks of creating connected neighbourhoods and cities and with services designed mainly for companies. Very often, it fosters economic growth affecting the price of rentals and services on offer. Sometimes, as a direct result of government actions.

This pushes residents out of neighbourhoods, only to be replaced by others with greater purchasing power. And, sometimes, these residential neighbourhoods are replaced with tourism neighbourhoods.

Digital education

“Successful cities will be those that are able to integrate large numbers of citizens from generally rural areas or with less possibilities of finding work and which address elderly people’s needs”, according to Joan Cornet, director of the European Connected Health Alliance and ex-civil servant in the European Commission and the European Parliament.

One of the challenges of smart cities is to design plans that integrate people with limited, or no digital skills, or those without internet access. Particularly in cities in which sectors such as health or transport are digitalised. In Europe or the US, which have large communities of elderly people, taking action in this regard is crucial.Guaranteeing the integration of people with disabilities in new buildings and infrastructures is another priority when planning cities. Projects such as Smart Cities for all provide governments, organisations and companies with the tools and strategies required to build more inclusive smart cities.

The main challenge is to foster growth, without cities becoming “islands” of services for companies. Focusing on citizens, and not just those with stronger purchasing power. Starting, of course, with those that already live there.

Who is most at risk of social exclusion in a city?

The demographics of social exclusion are far more complex than they may seem. Of course, people living in poverty, unskilled workers, migrants who have yet to learn the language of their host country and single-parent families will face problems finding jobs and making meaningful social connections that would bring positive change to their lives. But there are other groups that don't fit these requisites, yet they are severely at risk of being excluded from society.

For example, an article published on the International Journal of Social Psychology points towards mental health being a primary factor in social exclusion. Based on data collected by the social services from the Basque Country, Spain, there's a strong correlation between mental illness and risk of exclusion, with the interesting point of women, despite having a smaller income, being in better sociocultural position than men, who tend to be more isolated. An important point, given how social interactions are critical in order to improve one's position.

Meanwhile, research made in Barcelona singles out insecurity as another potential factor. Thus, people can have jobs and stability, but just by living in a dangerous neighborhood ridden with crime and public health issues they are more at risk of being excluded. That's what is often known as living on the edge. These people are not only facing dangers that could set them away from society, but they live in neighborhoods that tend to be looked down upon and less involved in community and civic participation, which can act as safety networks.

Making a ranked list of which circumstances contribute to exclusion would be difficult, as different problems carry different specific weight depending on the city and country. After all, it's not the same to suffer from a mental illness in a country with generous support policies towards these issues than in one that offers no aid at all, and that's just an example. Nevertheless, it's more or less evident that causes of social exclusion are numerous, varied and not always material.

Images | Unsplash/Chuttersnap, Unsplash/Florian Hoffman, Unsplash/Vlad Sargu

Related Content

Recommended profiles for you

Remember to activate your profile to network!
Activate profile
Lluis Moreno
Lluis Moreno
Ajuntament de Parets del Vallès
Councilor for Innovation, Participation and technical office for transversal projects
Maria Suarez Alvarez Alvarez
Maria Suarez Alvarez Alvarez
Linstone Housing Association
Johan Höglund
Johan Höglund
Carlos Martí
Carlos Martí
Ciudad Sostenible magazine / ICS Agency
Director ICS Agency / Ciudad Sostenible magazine
Daniela Andreia  Moreira de Sousa
Daniela Andreia Moreira de Sousa
Técnico Superior de Serviço Social
Rutsuko Tanaka
World Bank TDLC
Public Relations Officer TDLC
Tami Milner
Medical Coder
Katri Schulze
Business Tampere
Coordinator, Business Tampere, Smart Tampere Ecosystem Programme
Martin Coronado
Community Manager
Roy Kim
Roy Kim
Dot Incorporation
Chief Strategy Officer
MªAngels Morgó
Project Manager
Jon Aguirre Such
Jon Aguirre Such
National URBACT Point
Coordinator of National URBACT Point in Spain
Jorge Echavarría
Universidad Nacional de Colombia
Full Time Research Professor
Winarsih Win
Winarsih Win
Surabaya State University
mobilizing citizens to care for the environment both in society and on campus
Daniele Ornaghi Sant Anna
Daniele Ornaghi Sant Anna
Federal University of Itajubá
Elisenda Ardevol
Luis Marqués
Rovira i Virgili University
Dean of Faculty of Educational Sciences an Phsycology
Ana Zuluaga
Marca Ciudad Rionegro
Chief Maketing and Strategy
Mongi Henda
City of Cape Town
Assistant Professional Officer
Nicole La Iacona
City of Mechelen
funding advisor

Only accessible for registered users
This content is available only for registered users
TO: $$toName$$
SUBJECT: Message from $$fromName$$