This article is available also in spanish here
What is the theory of Doughnut Economics and how can it mold cities?
My list

Author | Lucía Burbano

The term 'Doughnut Economics' was first coined by the British economist Kate Raworth in a report published in Oxfam in 2012 and which she subsequently continued to develop in her book 'Doughnut Economics: seven ways to think like a 21st century economist'. In both, she proposes a new humanist economic model, a tool which many cities worldwide are starting to use.

What is the doughnut theory or the theory of Doughnut economics?

The theory of the Doughnut formula is a change of economic model as a response to humanity's major challenge: eradicating global poverty all within the means of the planet's limited natural resources.

It receives this name because it is visually represented by two doughnut-shaped discs: the one in the center is the social foundation, which includes basic fundamental rights, and the outer ring is the ecological ceiling, which cannot be exceeded if we are to guarantee the prosperity of humanity. In the middle would be the doughnut, understood as the space in which humanity can progress if the planet's boundaries are respected. Both circumferences coincide with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDG).

This change of paradigm proposes shifting from an economic model of constant growth measured by Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and realizing that, in the end, economic prosperity depends on human and natural wellbeing. To achieve this, it proposes transforming governance systems, making these regenerative and distributive instead of finite and egotistical.

Doughnut Economics 8

What are the limits of the Doughnut model in order to prosper?

The economist identifies nine environmental thresholds that should not be exceeded in order to avoid further natural degradation that jeopardizes the health of the Planet even more: climate change, biodiversity loss, ocean acidification, land conversion, freshwater withdrawals, nitrogen and phosphorus loading, chemical pollution, air pollution and ozone layer depletion.

In turn, there are 12 essential social goals for humanity to prosper, many of which are basic human rights: food safety, a living income, water and sanitation, healthcare, education, energy, gender equality, social equity, resilience, participation, employment, networks and access to housing.

How can this theory alleviate life in cities?

Cities can act as transforming agents of this change proposed by Raworth. Amsterdam, Brussels, Melbourne or Berlin are examples of cities joining the "doughnut effect" and are thus paving the way towards social and environmental sustainability. The starting point for all of them is similar: initiate broader participatory processes to identify possible solutions to their most pressing problems.

In order to incorporate the doughnut into their urban management models, cities must answer the following questions:

  • Objective: What or who does the city serve?
  • Networks: How is the city using its purchasing power and its networks?
  • Governance: How is the city governed? Who is included in decision-making processes?
  • Ownership? Who owns the city's sources of wealth?
  • Finances: Are the finances at the service of the city or the city at the service of the finances?

An example is Amsterdam which, after conducting this exercise, came face to face with the harsh reality: 20% of tenants cannot even cover their basic needs after paying their rent. Although the most obvious solution would be to build more houses, the city's CO2 emissions are 31% higher than they were in 1990. The strategy they have come up with to counteract the two problems is to implement laws making the use of recycled and natural materials mandatory in the construction sector.

Doughnut Economics 9Melbourne's Doughnut model

Criticisms of the doughnut model

The economist Branko Milanovic is one of the theory's main skeptics, arguing that Raworth's model does not take into account aspects such as the fact that without greater GDP growth, we will not eradicate global poverty. Likewise, current sustainable innovations are marginal and their progress is minimal compared with "what should happen".

Finally, Milanovic considers the book to portray globalized capitalism as entering into a "more cooperative and gentler phase", but in reality, citizens are becoming more commercially motivated, which is leading towards a self-centered, money- and success-oriented society, while transmitting a world that is "devoid of major social contradictions", and says there is no "we" that includes 7.3 billion people. Different class and national interests are fighting each other.

As tends to be the case with global development models, the one advocated by the doughnut theory sets out well-identified problems and their possible solutions, but that does not mean they are going to be true or applicable worldwide.

Without a series of universal solutions, which do not exist and will probably not exist, it will be up to the politicians and economists to assess whether it can be implemented successfully and, if so, to what extent.

Images | Unsplash/Patrick Fore, Arts and Craft/Doughnut Economics Action Lab, Sean Trewick/Regen Melbourne

Related content
What is the theory of Doughnut Economics and how can it mold cities?
What is the theory of Doughnut Economics and how can it mold cities?
How the pandemic revealed the fault lines in Asia’s economic success story
How the pandemic revealed the fault lines in Asia’s economic success story
Stronger Profits Through Circular Economy
Stronger Profits Through Circular Economy
Startups Pitch Competition
Startups Pitch Competition
Financing Models to Fuel Green Startups
Financing Models to Fuel Green Startups
Laia Bonet | Inspirational Talk | New Economic 2030 Agenda through Innovation
Laia Bonet | Inspirational Talk | New Economic 2030 Agenda through Innovation
Flagship Projects for NextGenerationEU Programme
Flagship Projects for NextGenerationEU Programme
The Recovery Plan for a Green & Digital Europe
The Recovery Plan for a Green & Digital Europe
Sustainability Meets Profitability
Sustainability Meets Profitability
Corporate Purpose: from Trend to Reality
Corporate Purpose: from Trend to Reality
Planet in Need. Business in Action
Planet in Need. Business in Action
Launch of Innovate Cities to Drive New Era of Smart City Innovation and Commercialization While Protecting Canadians' Privacy
Launch of Innovate Cities to Drive New Era of Smart City Innovation and Commercialization While Protecting Canadians' Privacy
From smart toilets to future finance: Stanford sets up Songdo cities lab
From smart toilets to future finance: Stanford sets up Songdo cities lab
What cities of the future can learn from the crypto world
What cities of the future can learn from the crypto world
China eyes intelligent manufacturing amid external risks
China eyes intelligent manufacturing amid external risks
Smart City startups to generate over $100Bn in five years
Smart City startups to generate over $100Bn in five years
Incheon Free Economic Zone: a successful case of local economic development in South Korea
Incheon Free Economic Zone: a successful case of local economic development in South Korea
How can digitalization ensure greater tax compliance?
How can digitalization ensure greater tax compliance?
UK business and consumer confidence jumps; markets rally on recovery hopes – as it happened
UK business and consumer confidence jumps; markets rally on recovery hopes – as it happened
Shopping with delivery robots arrives in cities
Shopping with delivery robots arrives in cities
Barcelona Provincial Council: this is how a smart region works
Barcelona Provincial Council: this is how a smart region works
[ui!] Urban Software Institute: Mobility for your whole life
[ui!] Urban Software Institute: Mobility for your whole life
Recycling and economics: a formula that only works if you believe in it
Recycling and economics: a formula that only works if you believe in it
When rubbish takes over cities: the circular economy as a solution to combat the accumulation of waste
When rubbish takes over cities: the circular economy as a solution to combat the accumulation of waste
Millennials and employment: Smart Cities as the setting for a new labour market
Millennials and employment: Smart Cities as the setting for a new labour market
Green cities and economic wealth, a 100% compatible team
Green cities and economic wealth, a 100% compatible team
How come cities such as Madrid, Peking or New York have more jobs?
How come cities such as Madrid, Peking or New York have more jobs?
How to finance the requirements of Smart Cities?
How to finance the requirements of Smart Cities?
The informal economy and developing countries: an engine of growth and a source of abuse
The informal economy and developing countries: an engine of growth and a source of abuse
Strategic networking: the glue that binds cities and industries together
Strategic networking: the glue that binds cities and industries together
Can an accessible city also be an economically viable city?
Can an accessible city also be an economically viable city?
The sustainable urbanisation value chain
The sustainable urbanisation value chain
From startup to scaleup: moving towards a new business approach
From startup to scaleup: moving towards a new business approach
Empowering small business in times of crisis
Empowering small business in times of crisis
How epidemics transformed London into one of the most state-of-the-art cities in the world
How epidemics transformed London into one of the most state-of-the-art cities in the world
x-tention: Towards post covid-19 smart tourism
x-tention: Towards post covid-19 smart tourism
Pebbles: How to avoid bottlenecks in the grid
Pebbles: How to avoid bottlenecks in the grid
Siemens eMobility: Energizing the electromobile world
Siemens eMobility: Energizing the electromobile world
Smart Buildings: Enabling reliability and resilience for a better future
Smart Buildings: Enabling reliability and resilience for a better future
SCHRÉDER EXEDRA: Lighting up cities
SCHRÉDER EXEDRA: Lighting up cities
The EU establishes rules to identify green investments and combat greenwashing
The EU establishes rules to identify green investments and combat greenwashing
Future is rural: a new vision for sustainable development
Future is rural: a new vision for sustainable development
Digitization enables new economy - Bingjiang IoT Town builts polit zone of digital economy development
Digitization enables new economy - Bingjiang IoT Town builts polit zone of digital economy development
Merwede, the Dutch neighbourhood where there will be one shared car for every 3 households
Merwede, the Dutch neighbourhood where there will be one shared car for every 3 households
AdvanGrid: Staying ahead in the energy transition
AdvanGrid: Staying ahead in the energy transition
Genetec Clearance: Putting a new face on crime solving
Genetec Clearance: Putting a new face on crime solving
Construtag: Know where your assets are, by IOTFactory
Construtag: Know where your assets are, by IOTFactory
EMER²GENT: data sharing to boost the economy after the pandemic
EMER²GENT: data sharing to boost the economy after the pandemic
Economic and social recovery leaving no one behind
Economic and social recovery leaving no one behind
The five best cities for women entrepreneurs
The five best cities for women entrepreneurs
Recommended profiles for you
Remember to activate your profile to network!
Activate profile
joost germis
joost germis
City of Antwerp
Chief of Staff to the Vice-Mayor
PS
Pravin Sinha
University of Hyderabad
Student
Alfredo Vega
Alfredo Vega
Xtrategas
Director
Xavier Carbó
Xavier Carbó
Xavier\'s Factory X
Founder
AS
Aliteia Santos Santos
Aliteia Santos
Ownet
AN
Alla Nabedrika
Moscow Export Center
Manager
UU
Umi Fatonah Umi
-
-
Ar.Mukund Patoliya
Ar.Mukund Patoliya
Mukund patel architects
Architect
AK
Anna Krywalski
Baden-Württemberg International
Regional Manager
TO
Tirso Ordaz
TS Aplicaciones Técnicas
Technical Director
Marcos Nahuel Martínez Staziani
Marcos Nahuel Martínez Staziani
Universidad Nacional del Sur
Administrative clerk
AG
ARİF GEÇGEL
kavak belediye başkanlığı samsun
MUHASEBECİ
eduardo.leite leite
eduardo.leite leite
Agência de desenvolvimento leste paulista Sul de minas
Business Development
Juliette Moulinier
Juliette Moulinier
Swapbook
-
Teddy Asril
Teddy Asril
EWC
Project Manager
Osmar Dalquano Junior
Osmar Dalquano Junior
Retail2Engage
Director - Relationship and Business
Ari Wahyudi
Ari Wahyudi
Land Office of Muaro Jambi Regency
Head of Section of Land Office Arrangement of Muaro Jami Regency
Yoottana Booranrom
Yoottana Booranrom
OZEN CO., LTD.
Managing Director
bs
beny saad
Financial advisor
Financial advisor
Ritam Roy
Ritam Roy
CityKey Fin
I am the founder & CEO of the company.

Only accessible for registered users
This content is available only for registered users
TO: $$toName$$
SUBJECT: Message from $$fromName$$