5 common mistakes in urban gardening plans
This article is also available here in Spanish.

5 common mistakes in urban gardening plans

My list

Author | M. Martínez Euklidiadas

Urban gardening plans are the municipal guidelines that help with the management of gardens and urban vegetation, and provide ideas on the design or budgets for them. Do they take into account species that trigger allergies, invasive species, water usage or climate resistance?

What is an urban garden?

An urban garden is a green area within a city in which all types of plants are grown: flowers, herbaceous plants, low growing shrubs, trees, etc.

Urban gardens serve many purposes. Although they have always tended to be used as a purely decorative or ostentatious element in palaces, today, they satisfy different needs, including:

Aesthetic function, particularly when there is a certain composition involved This can be through flowers, trimming bushes into shapes or simply rewilding the environment.

Water filtration function. Gardens, unlike pavements, allow water to reach the subsoil. Rain gardens are a form of garden specifically designed for this low-cost drainage system.

Pollution fighting function.Vegetation acts as a filter for particulates, absorbing noise and cooling the air.

Common errors when designing an urban garden

Some of the most common errors found in urban gardening include:

1. Use of non-local species

parks and gardens 2

Green lawns and striking colorful flowers are commonly found in gardening, but often they are not local or endemic species. The costs of nutrients and water in these gardens is extremely high, which is a problem in dry climates.

Ideally local plants should be used. Although green lawns have greater presence and the flowers are aesthetically "more attractive" (obviously, this is subjective), rockrose or an aloe vera plant require very little water.

2. Pulling out or cutting ‘weeds’

‘Non-productive’ or unaesthetic plants have been classified as ‘weeds’ when they in fact do a vital job in ecosystems. Some help to condense droplets that permeate the soil and reach nearby plants. Others bring  nutrients up from the soil for other neighboring plants that cannot reach them. Some people ‘abandon’ gardens as part of a horticultural disobedience aimed at ecological restoration.

3. Planting allergy-triggering, toxic and thorny species

Not everyone is allergic to the same compounds, but there are some relatively universal allergens that affect a considerable percentage of the population. Avoiding planting them and looking for alternatives is always possible because there are local substitute species (that can occupy the ecological niche of another) for practically any species. Likewise, it is worth avoiding species that are toxic to people and pets; or those with thorns.

4. Planting invasive species

An invasive plant can wreak havoc in an urban ecosystem  -which is already significantly vulnerable due to the fragility of the ecosystem- regardless of how pretty it is. Learning about invasive species by checking the catalogue with a specialist is always a good option.

5. Not having a clear idea of the purpose of the urban garden

Why are we planting in cities, is a question that all urban planners should ask themselves, because not all species behave in the same way or have the same benefits and co-benefits. Apart from providing more shade, others are home to more insects, and others are nutrient fixing, etc.

It is not always possible to maximize everything, and it is important to understand the reasons for the garden. To filter water? Prevent heat? Compensate the gray infrastructure? Serve as an anchor for other species? Municipal technicians, often through rapid tactical urbanism measures, can experiment in order to identify better urban solutions.

Images |  Chris Chatham, duong chung

Related content

Recommended profiles for you

EB
Elisabet Berges Franco
Aigües de Barcelona
NS
Nickson Simiyu
Technical University of Mombasa
EP
Eva Ma. París Sánchez
Agència de l'habitatge
Cap d'àrea del Control del Parc
MS
Maria Teresa Santonato
EREDA SLU
Technical Director
AR
Alonzo Romero
The Predictive Company
CEO
DC
Diego Cammarano
IPCC /Universite Paris-Saclay
TT
Theodoros Tsevas
McAllen & Warden SA
Co Founder
JP
Juan Carlos Puga Martin
Voluntario
Voluntario
NC
Noah Chongo
Climate Protection Zambia
AL
Alexander Lehnert
Lidbot
Co-founder of the company and Head of Design
RJ
Raul Jimenez
UASLP
PB
Pedro Andrés Bravo Sánchez
Gobernación del Valle
BRAVO & ASOCIADOS GROUP S.A.S.
NR
Nevena Rikalo
freelancer at OneWorks
KR
Kevin Reperuga
EPWMD
Database
AS
Aarti Shah
Co-REGEN
NG
Niklas Gemp
Nexol Photovolthermic AG
CEO
NM
Nicola Mitolo
Snap4City / DISIT Lab
Co-Manager of Industry4.0 and Smart-City projects Dissemination Responsible
WF
williams flores
SudaEner SA
manager
HS
Harris Schaer
NYC Dept. of Cultural Affairs
Director of Energy and Sustainability
JM
Julia Moreno
Forética
Senior Manager. Responsible for Climate Change and Urban Sustainabii

Are we building the cities we really need?

Explore Cartography of Our Urban Future —a bold rethink of ‘smart’ cities and what we must change by 2030.