Smart city community engagement: 4D IVR in city planning process
My list

Authors | Mahbubur Meenar and Hunter Swanson

In the last several decades, virtual reality (or VR)—a computer technology to create simulated environments—has become increasingly popular. One tends to think of its possibilities primarily in entertainment, such as video games using VR headsets. But immersive VR, or IVR, can do much more than enhancing your favorite game—it can also play an important role in city planning. In particular, IVR can potentially increase public engagement in the city planning process by making stakeholders more familiar with design or development proposals through a simulation in an immersive environment. Viewers can get a better understanding of a project through a simulation in front of their eyes. Recorded videos of 3D models of a design proposal can only do so much, but IVR provides the possibility of exploring a development proposal in an immersive environment, no matter where you are or how far the project is located.

Urban planners have been embracing digital technologies such as social media, participatory Geographic Information Systems (GIS) mapping, and IVR to complement or enhance traditional public engagement techniques (such as meetings and surveys), in hopes of supporting different forms of e-governments and smart cities. IVR itself provides a way for humans to interact with computers and complex data and visualization. A key component of the IVR is the degree to which the technology is immersive, engaging the mind and body of users through sight, sound, smell, and/or touch.

VR-Scene

To see the true impact of IVR, researchers from Rowan University Community Planning + Visualization Lab (USA) conducted a study using focus groups to examine reactions to multidimensional and multisensory IVR by simulating a fictional planning scenario in Glassboro, New Jersey, a small urban community with 20,000 year-round residents, and another 18,000 students attending Rowan University. This study focused on a three-block section of the town’s historic downtown. The project team—comprised on planners, architects, and engineers—partnered with the city to conduct a community design workshop and gather ideas for a potential development in the study area. A group of 46 attendees, including municipal officials, residents, business owners, and university students and faculty, participated in this workshop. Based on the outputs from this workshop, the project team created a fictional planning scenario, including site plan and 3D models using various software packages such as Google Earth, Google SketchUp, and ESRI ArcGIS 3D Analyst.

Next, Rowan University’s VR Center created an IVR version of the 3D models. The VR Center has a lab, featuring a 7-foot-high by 40-foot-wide curved wall of eight adjoining screens and provides room for up to 10-15 people to explore VR simulations. The IVR version included virtual 3D props such as people, cars, street furniture, and placemaking features. In order to create a 4D IVR simulation, the project team also designed sound stimuli (such as restaurant chatter, street traffic, and lawnmower noise) and smell stimuli (such as freshly cut grass and buttered popcorn). A 7-minute fly-through and walk-through simulation, overlaid with voice narrations, was recorded to create a virtual walking experience through the design proposal.

DSC0054

Forty focus group participants experimented with various formats of IVR (3D and multisensory 4D) and compared them with standard presentation formats typically used as public engagement tools. The project team found that participation generally increased with multi-sensory and multi-dimensional IVR simulations. Focus group participants had a better memory recall of design scenarios, higher level of emotional attachments to proposed scenarios, and asked more questions or made additional comments about the design proposals, as well as the technology.

The participants identified several strengths and limitations of this technology. To start, they thought 4D IVR elevated their sensory experience and emotional responses to the proposed design, leading to a better understanding of scale and navigability of design proposals. In contrast, some of them faced motion sickness and discomfort due to IVR technology. And some participants had low buy-in in the proposed design due to visual and sensory design flaws. Others also pointed out the potential issues of increased time and budget for public engagement.

The project team concluded that multisensory and multidimensional 4D IVR offers city planners the opportunity to diversify their usual community engagement techniques. The study suggests that “in this digital age of public engagement, multi-sensory 4D IVR technology offers urban planners and policy makers an opportunity to diversify or supplement standard public engagement processes.” As there are some disadvantages to IVR such as price, accessibility, physical discomfort, and age favoring, IVR should be used as a supplement to the standard methods used in public engagement, but not replace them.

Though this study was small in scale and completed on a constrained budget, it still highlights the additional dimensions that IVR can bring to the public engagement process. Hopefully a future study can also focus on “completed" planning or urban design projects that used IVR technology as a public engagement tool; even studying how engagement through IVR simulations can contribute to the final design and development of completed projects.

Dr. Mahbubur Meenar is a faculty member in the Geography, Planning, and Sustainability Department at Rowan University, USA. His research areas include digital civic engagement, green infrastructure, urban food environment, and sustainable development. Mr. Hunter Swanson is a research assistant at Rowan University’s Community Planning + Visualization Lab.

For more information, please read the original research article published in Urban Science journal, available as an open-source material following this link.

Images | Mahbubur Meenar (IVR simulation), Samain Sabrin (rendering), Lux Interaction.

Related content
Jakarta is sinking and now Indonesia has to find a new capital
Jakarta is sinking and now Indonesia has to find a new capital
Digital twins and urban planning: how to use replicas to building the cities of tomorrow
Digital twins and urban planning: how to use replicas to building the cities of tomorrow
Smart Cube: Cube4Services
Smart Cube: Cube4Services
BSI Cleaning: Innovative cleaning and disinfection solutions
BSI Cleaning: Innovative cleaning and disinfection solutions
Wave by AGC: WAVEATTOCH, transparent glass antenna for outdoor network densification
Wave by AGC: WAVEATTOCH, transparent glass antenna for outdoor network densification
Wallbox Chargers: QUASAR
Wallbox Chargers: QUASAR
Lumency: Smart Building and Environmental Monitoring
Lumency: Smart Building and Environmental Monitoring
Open Digital Twin Framework: Twinning livability factors for good
Open Digital Twin Framework: Twinning livability factors for good
5G Smart Environmental Protection: Water at its best
5G Smart Environmental Protection: Water at its best
5G Smart Factory: Supporting the transformation of the manufacturing industry
5G Smart Factory: Supporting the transformation of the manufacturing industry
x-tention: Towards post covid-19 smart tourism
x-tention: Towards post covid-19 smart tourism
Arca: Wave control for better health
Arca: Wave control for better health
Pebbles: How to avoid bottlenecks in the grid
Pebbles: How to avoid bottlenecks in the grid
Unicard: Multimodal transport made easy
Unicard: Multimodal transport made easy
Urban Vision Engagement Project: Harnessing the power of Virtual Reality
Urban Vision Engagement Project: Harnessing the power of Virtual Reality
Daizy: Making IoT accessible to anyone
Daizy: Making IoT accessible to anyone
Smart Buildings: Rethinking workplace strategies in the New Normal
Smart Buildings: Rethinking workplace strategies in the New Normal
Passenger: Enabling transport innovation
Passenger: Enabling transport innovation
Siemens eMobility: Energizing the electromobile world
Siemens eMobility: Energizing the electromobile world
Xpernest: Handy tools to ensure a successful social distancing
Xpernest: Handy tools to ensure a successful social distancing
Clever Bins: Enhancing recycling management
Clever Bins: Enhancing recycling management
Huawei Intelligent Operation Center: The brain and central nervous system of a Smart City
Huawei Intelligent Operation Center: The brain and central nervous system of a Smart City
Smart Buildings: Enabling reliability and resilience for a better future
Smart Buildings: Enabling reliability and resilience for a better future
Microsoft: A strong commitment to a planet-size challenge
Microsoft: A strong commitment to a planet-size challenge
Smart City and Region Energy: Sizing up the energy transition
Smart City and Region Energy: Sizing up the energy transition
Cyclomedia: Streets speak out smart
Cyclomedia: Streets speak out smart
MetroTaifun: Keeping trash out of sight
MetroTaifun: Keeping trash out of sight
IFSB's greenhouse: A Circular Ecoomy approach to construction projects
IFSB's greenhouse: A Circular Ecoomy approach to construction projects
SCHRÉDER EXEDRA: Lighting up cities
SCHRÉDER EXEDRA: Lighting up cities
The city designed by Leonardo da Vinci that was centuries ahead of its time
The city designed by Leonardo da Vinci that was centuries ahead of its time
The green transition: buildings that will combat climate change
The green transition: buildings that will combat climate change
These were the urban utopias that preceded us - Infographic
These were the urban utopias that preceded us - Infographic
Head in the clouds - Feet on the ground: radical solutions for the skyscrapers of the future
Head in the clouds - Feet on the ground: radical solutions for the skyscrapers of the future
Proptech: Marketplaces and virtual reality conquer the real estate industry
Proptech: Marketplaces and virtual reality conquer the real estate industry
Smart city community engagement: 4D IVR in city planning process
Smart city community engagement: 4D IVR in city planning process
Vietnam to build a smart city from scratch
Vietnam to build a smart city from scratch
Smarter cities are born with digital twins
Smarter cities are born with digital twins
L'Hospitalet, Resilient City. Promoting inclusive and sustainable development
L'Hospitalet, Resilient City. Promoting inclusive and sustainable development
ArcGIS: Building smart communities for good governance
ArcGIS: Building smart communities for good governance
The UN endorses a computerized simulation to increase the level of global development
The UN endorses a computerized simulation to increase the level of global development
Recommended profiles for you
Danny Bwalya
Danny Bwalya
UPV/EHU
Masters Degree Student
Olga Korshunov
Olga Korshunov
Minute.ly
BA degree in Sustainability and Government. Seeking a new opportunity.
Simeon Shtebunaev
Simeon Shtebunaev
Birmingham City University
Doctoral Researcher in Youth and Smart Cities
SUDUNG M SITUMORANG SITUMORANG
SUDUNG M SITUMORANG SITUMORANG
HIGH STANDARD CONSULTANT
Consultant Engineering
WK
William Kwok
Johnson controls indonesia
Operations manager
pG
paloma GONZALEZ
citd
Bussiness development manager
Frederik Boersma
Frederik Boersma
Geobimexperts
Owner
PV
Prakash Verma
Buildefi
Architect
FM
Francisco Martins
Escola Superior de Tecnologia de Viseu
Professor
Stefan  Merkle
Stefan Merkle
Immobilien Zeitung
Specialized on digital transformation in real estate @ImmoZeitung / Germany
Pia Fischer
Pia Fischer
Nordic Edge
Chief Concept Manager
KS
Kuldeep Sharma
Civil
Supervisor
TV
Tom Van Uffelen
Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise
Country Director
Andres Assmus
Andres Assmus
CityZeen
Strategy
JP
Jürgen Pruss
Dell Technologies
Account Executive Public - Digital Cities
Dharm Singh Jat
Dharm Singh Jat
Namibia University of Acience and Technology
Professor
SE
SILVIA ESCALERAS
SECRETARÍA GENERAL DE SEGURIDAD Y GOBERNABILIDAD
TÉCNICO DE RIESGOS
AZ
Alexandre Zelinski
IncludeIoT
Director
AA
Abdulrahman Abdulhak
SABSRE
Projects manager
Muhamad Meiza Jolanda Meiza
Muhamad Meiza Jolanda Meiza
MITI
Staff

Only accessible for registered users
This content is available only for registered users
TO: $$toName$$
SUBJECT: Message from $$fromName$$