The sustainable urbanisation value chain
My list

Author | Pablo Vaggione

The importance of cities as a foremost development topic of the hour has been recognised in the several global agendas that have been endorsed by national governments since 2015. The Agenda 2030 for Sustainable Development, a global vision and a landmark commitment subscribed by both developed and developing countries includes an explicit goal for cities, Goal 11, among its Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). This is a step forward from the Millennium Development Goals, which referred to urban issues only through a sub-indicator and signals a shift in the approach to urban development, from a problem to be controlled, to embracing cities as a key part of the growth agenda.

In this setting, local governments are increasingly compelled to address complexity and opportunity so that cities can be a driver for national economic growth, social cohesion and environmental safeguarding. However, if cities don’t take a leading role, or don’t have the means to deliver, national governments will not fulfil the goals they’ve committed to. Accelerating the fulfilment of the SDGs is a key raison d'être of the New Urban Agenda (NUA), a non-binding consensus which depicts an aspirational, qualitative reference that cities can embed, if they choose to, into their urban development instruments, including planning, prioritisation, budgeting and monitoring.

If cities don’t take a leading role, or don’t have the means to deliver, national governments will not fulfil the goals they’ve committed to

Whilst the Agenda has built momentum in stakeholder awareness and political discourse, what “implementation” implies on the field, and its business model, is not completely clear yet. The benefits that local governments would attain if they were to apply the NUA are not quantified to the degree of detail that would help moving to an operational level. Observed from the ground, the New Urban Agenda could seem like an airplane, full of committed advocates, but permanently on a holding pattern. While the perspective at 30,000 feet is necessary for big picture policy, the disconnection from what happens daily on the ground is a weakness that requires attention. Agendas can turn into wish lists, and eventually remain forgotten on a drawer, if they do not have a people-centred implementation framework that is focused on tangible change.

Sustainable urbanisation will not happen spontaneously, nor the correlation between urban development and economic growth is automatically positive. Although cities may be receptive to qualitative references and decision makers, to some extent, can lend a sympathetic ear to theory, generating urban value and sustaining performance requires frameworks that trigger agglomeration advantages, contain risks, empower fruitful partnerships, and generate accountability. In short, policy makers, investors and stakeholders need a roadmap that enables moving from good ideas and pilot projects to the delivery of change at scale.

An approach to improve the connection of global agendas to people-centred decisions is the sustainable urbanisation value chain. The value chain, a business management concept introduced by Professor Michael Porter[1], is the full range of activities that an organisation conducts to bring a product or service from conception to delivery. If we imagine the global agendas as a raw material, then the value chain consists on everything that is added from the conception to the delivery of a product (city interventions) to beneficiaries (the people living in cities).

If the value chain is continuous, the origin of urban interventions can be traced back to global agendas, which provides legitimacy

The sustainable urbanisation value chain is a conceptual map from global agendas to interventions which I had the opportunity to propose and use while I oversaw the UN-Habitat office in Mexico. In practice, the application of the value chain to city development begins with a gap analysis with the SDGs, the NAU and other relevant global, national and subnational agendas. Through concatenated activities such as the generation of evidence, integrated diagnostics, strategic and binding planning, the design of collective intelligence spaces so that the participation of stakeholders generates shared responsibility, and the identification and prioritisation of projects, the intent is to reach the operational stage of an intervention in the most favourable implementation conditions.

The pilot application in several municipalities, for example, in Mérida, revealed that a connection between urban development activities, from vision to investment, is essential. If the value chain is continuous, the origin of urban interventions can be traced back to global agendas, which provides legitimacy . Furthermore, interventions identified through evidence and collective input acquire a sense of objectivity and inclusiveness. These are conditions for certainty which are very valuable when mobilising resources and for implementation continuity through changing political cycles.

A key aspect of the value chain is its focus on helping cities put their assets at the service of people

A logical and clear value chain can help parties to identify where and how they can generate urban value. If chain links are coordinated, sectors will have a common reference to work together. The synergies between, for example, those responsible for land use and housing policies, social mortgage institutions and developers would generate added value that can be passed on to homebuyers if the regulatory framework is adequate. Information transparency, which is essential for this to happen, is an area of opportunity that the smart city sector can consider.

A key aspect of the value chain is its focus on helping cities put their assets at the service of people, including demographics, information, technology, nature, location and systems of government. Historically, cities that have successfully taken advantage of their assets have had a strong understanding of the value chain. In Paris’ 1850 massive urban regeneration, driven by the need to maintain competitiveness in a new global order, the office of Baron George Haussmann had powers to coordinate planning and design; tax collection and budget execution; and the operation and maintenance of streets, public markets, schools and hospitals. This arrangement enabled a rapid progress from plan to implementation.

The value chain can already be a sounding board for cities and decision maker

Value chains can be broken in several instances, which creates difficulties for cities to generate and maintain value. This is evident in real estate bubbles, abandoned social housing, precarious settlements, ghost towns and bankrupt local governments. Weak links can consist, for example, in inaccurate baseline and forecast data, excessively long plan formulation periods, weak execution capacity, and the granting of construction permits disconnected from the value chain. An example of data inaccuracy is the case of the Shanghai 2020 plan, prepared in the late 1990s during a 7-year process. The plan projected a population of 16 million by 2020, but the city reached that amount in 2001.

The value chain is an approach to sustainable urbanisation that can be further developed to understand its potential as a people-centric policy guideline. __ It is a concept that is robust in its simplicity; the most efficient manner to develop it is through application. In the meantime, the value chain can already be a __sounding board for cities and decision makers that are asking themselves if current strategic choices will produce the desired outcomes, if their institutional structure enables enforcement and execution, if sectors are working together to their best capacity, if conditions can generate a return-risk ratio that is acceptable for urban investment, and, especially, how to meet needs and aspirations from present and future generations living in cities.

[1] Porter M (1998) Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. New York: Free Press

Pablo Vaggione is a urban development specialist and the former coordinator of the UN-HABITAT office for Mexico and Cuba"

Related content
Shopping with delivery robots arrives in cities
Shopping with delivery robots arrives in cities
Regional Government of Barcelona: this is how a smart region works
Regional Government of Barcelona: this is how a smart region works
[ui!] Urban Software Institute: Mobility for your whole life
[ui!] Urban Software Institute: Mobility for your whole life
Recycling and economics: a formula that only works if you believe in it
Recycling and economics: a formula that only works if you believe in it
Green cities and economic wealth, a 100% compatible team
Green cities and economic wealth, a 100% compatible team
How come cities such as Madrid, Peking or New York have more jobs?
How come cities such as Madrid, Peking or New York have more jobs?
How to finance the requirements of Smart Cities?
How to finance the requirements of Smart Cities?
The informal economy and developing countries: an engine of growth and a source of abuse
The informal economy and developing countries: an engine of growth and a source of abuse
Strategic networking: the glue that binds cities and industries together
Strategic networking: the glue that binds cities and industries together
Empowering small business in times of crisis
Empowering small business in times of crisis
x-tention: Towards post covid-19 smart tourism
x-tention: Towards post covid-19 smart tourism
Pebbles: How to avoid bottlenecks in the grid
Pebbles: How to avoid bottlenecks in the grid
Siemens eMobility: Energizing the electromobile world
Siemens eMobility: Energizing the electromobile world
Smart Buildings: Enabling reliability and resilience for a better future
Smart Buildings: Enabling reliability and resilience for a better future
SCHRÉDER EXEDRA: Lighting up cities
SCHRÉDER EXEDRA: Lighting up cities
The EU establishes rules to identify green investments and combat greenwashing
The EU establishes rules to identify green investments and combat greenwashing
Future is rural: a new vision for sustainable development
Future is rural: a new vision for sustainable development
Digitization enables new economy - Bingjiang IoT Town builts polit zone of digital economy development
Digitization enables new economy - Bingjiang IoT Town builts polit zone of digital economy development
AdvanGrid: Staying ahead in the energy transition
AdvanGrid: Staying ahead in the energy transition
Genetec Clearance: Putting a new face on crime solving
Genetec Clearance: Putting a new face on crime solving
Construtag: Know where your assets are, by IOTFactory
Construtag: Know where your assets are, by IOTFactory
EMER²GENT: data sharing to boost the economy after the pandemic
EMER²GENT: data sharing to boost the economy after the pandemic
Economic and social recovery leaving no one behind
Economic and social recovery leaving no one behind
The five best cities for women entrepreneurs
The five best cities for women entrepreneurs
A Conversation with Minister Takuya Hirai: a New Digitalization Strategy for Japan
A Conversation with Minister Takuya Hirai: a New Digitalization Strategy for Japan
EVcharge: eMobility made easy
EVcharge: eMobility made easy
Urban Water Management: Making every drop count
Urban Water Management: Making every drop count
MindSphere City Graph: Bringing the physical and digital world closer together
MindSphere City Graph: Bringing the physical and digital world closer together
Smart Pedestrian Crosswalk: Walking the city more safely
Smart Pedestrian Crosswalk: Walking the city more safely
Smartnodes: Realizing smart cities through smart lighting
Smartnodes: Realizing smart cities through smart lighting
Bikeep: Parking as simple as riding a bike
Bikeep: Parking as simple as riding a bike
Retail Banking Channels Post COVID-19 - Focus on More Efficient Operating Practices to Further Shape Bank Strategies and Customer Engagement
Retail Banking Channels Post COVID-19 - Focus on More Efficient Operating Practices to Further Shape Bank Strategies and Customer Engagement
Where are the profitable tech firms in Southeast Asia?
Where are the profitable tech firms in Southeast Asia?
5 ways digital business will change in 2021
5 ways digital business will change in 2021
Digital tools for any occasion
Digital tools for any occasion
Beyond leadership:
Beyond leadership: "leaderful teams"
How to improve your decisions
How to improve your decisions
Remote work: a crash course
Remote work: a crash course
Diversity at work
Diversity at work
Blockchain, Bitcoin & more
Blockchain, Bitcoin & more
The rise of sharing economy
The rise of sharing economy
What is your Business Model?
What is your Business Model?
Emerging retail trends to know
Emerging retail trends to know
Airvoice: how smart can urban furniture be?
Airvoice: how smart can urban furniture be?
TiaGo Delivery: it knows how to make you keep your distance
TiaGo Delivery: it knows how to make you keep your distance
SIARQ: Featuring Environmental Data As A Service
SIARQ: Featuring Environmental Data As A Service
The pandemic has revealed the cracks in US manufacturing: Here’s how to fix them
The pandemic has revealed the cracks in US manufacturing: Here’s how to fix them
Smart stimulus: Cash as code
Smart stimulus: Cash as code
Data-as-a-Service – New Business Paradigm Across Organizations
Data-as-a-Service – New Business Paradigm Across Organizations
When the pandemic ends, these are the places you want to invest
When the pandemic ends, these are the places you want to invest
Recommended profiles for you
Remember to activate your profile to network!
Activate profile
KJ
Kadambari Johri
BFSI
Marketing and Media
CS
Chaitanya Soni
La Grande Events & Promotions
Event Promotion
Ar.Mukund Patoliya
Ar.Mukund Patoliya
Mukund patel architects
Architect
Michel Araujo
Michel Araujo
WORLD Micro
Diretor Comercial
Juliette Moulinier
Juliette Moulinier
Swapbook
-
DV
Diego Valderrama
Independent
Researcher and desingner.
JM
JAVIER MARTI
grupinver3000
university teacher
Xavier Carbó
Xavier Carbó
Xavier\'s Factory X
Founder
JW
Jovi Wen
GlobalWith
GEO
PD
Pablo Dosal
IE
Student MBA+Master in Real Estate
GG
Gerald Gerald rotikan
Rendering
Digital marketer
NSN Murty
NSN Murty
PwC
Partner & Leader, Smart Cities
GP
Guillermo Páez
Ucel
Director
dm
dalia maimon SCHIRAY
fEDERAL uNIVERSITY OF rIO DE jANEIRO
Head of Laboratory (LARES/IE/UFRJ)
Ne Nelly
Ne Nelly
Tech Green Venture Builder
Founder
Osmar Dalquano Junior
Osmar Dalquano Junior
Retail2Engage
Director - Relationship and Business
GAY Vincent
GAY Vincent
dooiTwell
COO
Massimo Franco
Massimo Franco
Miur
Caf imprese
MC
Martin Clark
Dynamic Blockchain Ventures
Cryptocurrency Consultant & Investor
Sebas  Marin
Sebas Marin
UdeA
Joven investigador

Only accessible for registered users
This content is available only for registered users
TO: $$toName$$
SUBJECT: Message from $$fromName$$