autonomous vehicle
This article is also available here in Spanish.

Cities are not ready (yet) for self-driving cars: these are the key aspects holding them back

My list

Authors | Jaime Ramos, Elvira Esparza

We will still have to wait for the great dream of driverless cars. Although manufacturers continue to present new models of driverless cars each year, autonomous vehicles still have a long way to go. What are the main obstacles and challenges?

Are there any self-driving cars on the road yet?

Autonomous Vehicles

Yes, there are. However, they are still in the experimental phase sine die. Programs to promote self-driving cars have increased exponentially in recent years. These can be seen in dozens of countries.

The Waymo self-driving car, for example, has covered countless kilometers with the Google logo on its white bodywork. The models have covered over 20 billion kilometers to date, improving the intelligence required to fulfil the ambitious promise of eliminating road fatalities.

Waymo in the United States has been joined by Baidu’s Apollo Go, which operates in the Chinese cities of Wuhan, Beijing, and Shenzhen, as well as by other local companies such as Pony.ai and WeRide.

There are more autonomous vehicles operating on city streets in China and the United States than in Europe, where their introduction is beginning to be announced in cities such as Munich and Madrid.  For now, China can be said to be further ahead in terms of urban adaptation thanks to its infrastructure, while the United States stands out in software development.

Rather than reporting how many autonomous vehicles are operating in cities, companies provide figures on the number of trips completed.  By the end of 2025, Baidu had completed 6 million trips in 10 Chinese cities, while Waymo had reached 1 million in three US cities.

However, both companies have experienced significant pauses in the expansion of their networks due to safety issues that forced them to temporarily take their vehicles off the road.

Why aren’t cities ready for autonomous driving?

Autonomous Vehicles

There are various obstacles making it difficult to introduce autonomous vehicles in cities. These range from technological challenges to safety concerns and regulatory issues.

Insufficient Digitalization

To operate without human supervision, autonomous vehicles need to achieve the highest level of automation and communicate constantly with their surroundings. However, most cities have an insufficient level of digitalization and lack smart traffic lights that can connect to networks or real-time maps that provide alerts about unexpected road conditions.

Poor signage or the presence of pedestrians can confuse autonomous vehicle sensors and computer vision systems. These sensors are also affected by weather conditions such as heavy rain or fog, which interfere with communication and cause vehicles to slow down or even come to a complete stop.

Dynamic and unpredictable environments

Autonomous Vehicles

Autonomous driving algorithms work well in structured environments such as highways, but they still encounter problems amid the chaos of urban traffic.  In cities such as San Francisco, where robotaxis operate, they have been found to freeze and fail to respond in emergency situations. When they detect the emergency lights of fire trucks, police vehicles, or ambulances, the vehicles’ software can freeze, causing traffic jams on city streets.

The situation in China is different because its autonomous vehicles are designed to navigate the chaotic urban environments of its cities.  Electric scooters on the streets, cyclists, and pedestrians crossing in unauthorized areas are all considered by autonomous driving systems in Chinese cities. The vehicles are equipped with sensors, cameras, and vehicle-to-infrastructure communication systems to facilitate autonomous driving. However, problems have also occurred, such as a network failure in the city of Wuhan that left 100 robotaxis stranded on the streets, bringing traffic in the city to a standstill.

Lack of unified regulatory frameworks

There are no common regulations governing the conflicts arising from the use of autonomous vehicles. There is a legal vacuum regarding criminal or civil liability when a traffic violation is committed or a pedestrian is struck, as there is no agreement on whether responsibility lies with the software manufacturer, the vehicle owner, or the operator. However, international regulations such as the world’s first regulatory framework approved by the UN require that responsibility in the event of an accident be clearly defined.

High economic costs

The economic costs involved in maintaining the equipment required by autonomous vehicles and the necessary urban infrastructure are another barrier to the deployment of these vehicles in cities and the development of autonomous public transportation.

What is still needed for their deployment

The widespread adoption of autonomous vehicles will depend on progress in several areas: systems capable of responding safely to unexpected situations, connected urban infrastructure, regulations that clearly define responsibilities, and financing models capable of covering the costs. Until these conditions are developed in a coordinated manner, autonomous vehicles will remain concentrated in certain areas, as their deployment will be a gradual process that varies considerably across cities and countries.

Images | iStock/Irik Bikmukhametov, Tesla Motors, Waymo, iStock/Sundry Photography

Related Content

Recommended profiles for you

DB
Daniel Bara
UC
Una Chernavska
MAUGLO
MB
Marco Bertoldo
aidea Italia Srl - aidea Co., Ltd.
Electric 3 Wheeler aidea AA Cargo Scooter business development manager
VP
valentin Porta
MOTIT WORLD
CEO
AP
Alkis Papazoglou
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
RJ
Rodrigo Jesus
ISEC
VA
Valérie Aubry
EITUM
JR
John Santiago Rafael
City of Dortmund
DD
Diana Dréan
Koelnmesse GmbH
Sales Manager
AT
Alberto Tinoco
TA arquitectura
VM
Victor Martin
Alstom
Bid Manager, Innovation and Business Development Engineer
MG
Massimiliano Gallo
Silatech
Innovation Manager
TP
tania papasotiriou
the univercity of newcastle
MA
MANUEL AMADOR CAYUELA
PATENTES TALGO S.L.
IV
Inês Viegas
TISpt
Executive Board Member / Consultant
SM
Sergi Martínez-Abarca
ATM
Head of Management Transport
RM
Ridouane Mesbah
Agadir Municipality
FB
Federico Bosio
Tranzer B.V,
Business development manager - Italy
EK
Eftychia Koliou
Smart Transportation Alliance
OU
Onur Uçar
Feka Automotive

Are we building the cities we really need?

Explore Cartography of Our Urban Future —a bold rethink of ‘smart’ cities and what we must change by 2030.