predictive justice
This article is also available here in Spanish.

Predictive justice keeps marching on: increased security or dystopia?

My list

Author | Lucía Burbano

Through learning patterns based on public data on violent and property crimes,scientists from the University of Chicago have developed a new algorithm that can predict future crimes one week in advance with about 90% accuracy. This is where some questions arise, but one in particular, will artificial intelligence be the new justice tool?

What is predictive justice?

Despite sounding extremely modern, jurimetrics or predictive justice is a concept that first emerged in 1949 thanks to Lee Loevinger, an American jurist who proposed using statistics and mathematical probability as a response to certain legal issues. He summarized his idea in an article published that year by the Minnesota Law Review.

Obviously, algorithms and Artificial Intelligence (AI) did not exist seventy years ago, and today they can imitate cognitive processes and make decisions and resolve problems by analyzing millions of data. But the debate was already out there.

AI to predict crimes

predictive justice 2

Returning to the legal arena, Artificial Intelligence, on the one hand, reduces the time spent by Law professionals on preparing a case by analyzing millions of judicial decisions similar to those they are dealing with.

On the other hand, and focusing on predictive justice, the algorithms used by the study published by Victor Rotaru, Yi Huang, Timmy Li, James Evans and  Ishanu Chattopadhyay, use historical data in the city of Chicago on two major categories of reported incidents: violent crimes (homicides and assaults) and property offences (robberies and theft or vehicle robberies).

They chose these data because they are more likely to be reported to the police in urban areas in which there is distrust and lack of cooperation between citizens and law enforcement agencies. Apart from Chicago, this predictive system has already been tested in the cities of Atlanta, Austin, Detroit, Los Angeles, Philadelphia, Portland and San Francisco.

China, Israel, United Kingdom… the predictive justice map

Also in the United States, the start-up Predpol was created jointly in 2012 as a research project by the Los Angeles police department and UCLA. Bill Bratton, the commissioner at the time, wanted to find a way of using the COMPSTAT data, the organizational management tool used by police, to facilitate predictive recommendations about how and where new crimes may be committed.

Since then, this predictive justice tool has been protecting one in 33 people in the United States, according to its website. In Pennsylvania, for example, robberies are said to have been reduced by 23% thanks to this predictive system.

Another country that uses predictive technologies in its judicial system is China. Since 2017, the artificial intelligence company Megvii has been working on an AI system that analyzes hours of video recordings, looking for unusual patterns that may be illegal in order to inform the police.

And there are more examples. The Eurocop program, developed by the University of Castellón in Spain, is creating a predictive map of specific places and times in a city where a crime may be committed.

**Cambridge University **has the predictive intelligence project Hart; Italy, XLAW; Germany, Precobs; Japan, Vaak and Israel, Cortica, which is also used in India.

Discrepancies regarding the use of AI in justice

Not everyone agrees with the use of AI in police departments. The United Kingdom’s Liberty Human Rights expressed it disagreement alleging that the use of this programs is "discriminatory" and "dangerous".

"Our research has revealed that at least 14 police forces in the United Kingdom have used or intend to use discriminatory software algorithms to predict where offences will be committed and by whom. The predictive programs aren’t neutral. They are trained by people and rely on existing police data, and so they reflect patterns of discrimination and further embed them into police practice.", they argue.

Furthermore, they warn that the public is given "very little information" about how predictive algorithms reach their decisions — and even the police don’t understand how they do it. "This lack of transparency and understanding means these programs can’t be properly scrutinized".

Lastly, they are calling on police "to end their use of these dangerous and discriminatory programs".

The debate is guaranteed.

Photographs | Unsplash/Possessed Photography, Unsplash/Tingey Injury Law Firm

Related content

Recommended profiles for you

WK
Wendy King
Highregalia
CS
C S SHAJI Shaji
SVC IT consultancy
Director
MV
Márton Veres
Hungarian Development Promotion Office
AS
ajmal sayfullah
Rudram phronesis infraz pvt. ltd
JP
Jose Paiz
Grupo Cayala
DC
DUYGU CANAS DJANASH
Archroma Iberica SL
Procurement Manager
SG
Sonia Giovinazzi
JB
Jan Berka
Siemens
Sr. Solution architect of Smart Campus/City, overseeing projects in Middle East and Asia.
AT
Asan Tokpanov
AiFund
Project Manager
JJ
Jon Jaureguibeitia
Gobierno Vasco - Dept. Seguridad
IT Projects Chief.
HJ
Henry Jerez
Microsoft
CTO - Azure Edge Devices
JJ
jhoanatan jave
75360093
RO
Robert OKORN
Ljubljana Fire Brigade
Head of PR and Development
AC
Aubrie Cresswell
unifi.id
Head of U.S. Business Development
CD
Catalina Dominguez
Municipalidad de Las Condes
CP
Christian Pozzobon
Wmaker
Head
BO
Bernard Oosterbeek
Nuntius Tecnologia
General Manager
MS
MARIA MICHAELA SEBASTIANI
SIGMA INGEGNERIA SRL
GP
Giovanni Palombini
A2A SMART CITY
DS
Dayana Salvatierra
MUSEO

Are we building the cities we really need?

Explore Cartography of Our Urban Future —a bold rethink of ‘smart’ cities and what we must change by 2030.