This article is available also in spanish here

Gated communities: advantages and disadvantages for cities

My list

Author | Jaime Ramos

It seems inevitable that social differences will also affect physical urban spaces too. We see this in a very simplified way with expressions like "rich neighborhood" and "poor neighborhood". However, certain communities have taken the trend one step further by establishing physical barriers between groups of houses and the rest of the city.

What is a gated community?

There has been a boom in gated communities across the globe for decades since the end of the Second World War. These communities are areas of residential land on which a number of houses are built, sometimes even reaching one hundred units. Based on 2009 estimates, in the United States, where they are extremely popular, 11% of residential communities are gated communities.

One of the main characteristics of this concept are strictly-controlled entrances. These residential neighborhoods tend to be located a good distance from town centers and access is controlled by physical barriers or by making use of existing geographical features.

They have their own internal regulations governing coexistence, which begins with the freedom to drive and the use of their facilities, which can lead to legal disputes at a local level.

Advantages of gated communities

2

One of the main and most important advantages is the amount of security that private communities provide. This is thanks to a physical separation, which can end up also becoming a psychological separation.

But this is not the only advantage. Gated communities offer their own exclusive services, such as sports facilities, they provide greater privacy and do not tend to have external traffic problems such as traffic jams.

As with the physical barriers, they also have psychological component for residents, who may feel like they are members of an exclusive social group. This social class distinction through urban spaces existed in citadels of the past and it still exists today. One only has to look at the 1958 comedy movie Mon Oncle by Jacques Tati.

Disadvantages of gated communities

3

The subject-matter expert, Sonia Roitman, explains some of the issues as follows: "Gated communities may benefit the families that live in them, by providing safety or quality recreational spaces. But they hinder the city and society in general (...)"

Roitman believes they restrict public spaces, fostering the idea of privatization that has a negative impact on social cohesion and the development of open and democratic cities designed to combat discrimination.

This is in terms of social segregation, however, gated communities may also generate certain economic disparities, by altering property prices.

In some countries, gated communities are almost an exception. There are significant contrasts, such as the 11 million homes on gated communities in Argentina, compared with 100,000 in the United Kingdom, at the beginning of the millennium.

There are patterns that determine the proliferation of gated communities, such as the case of Japan, where they are not very popular and which, in contrast to other countries in which they are widespread, enjoys a high level of wellbeing and low crime rates.

Unlike Japan, in Poland gated communities are increasing in popularity, but these too have had their fair share of controversy, for example the housing estate in Silesia that has banned children.

Aleksandra Kunce, an expert at the University of Katowice, tries to describe the psychological effects such as anxiety associated with this of urban design. She describes gated communities as bunkers that make you feel safe, while still looking out for the enemy.

Under this idea, it seems highly unlikely that the enemy of these communities in the Polish region of Silesia are children. Jacques Tati and, therefore, Mr. Hulot, would be horrified today to see a phenomenon which they criticized when it first emerged.

Images | iStock/Michael Anthony, iStock/rodclementphotography, Wikimedia Commons

Related Content
9 electronic devices to make life easier for seniors
9 electronic devices to make life easier for seniors
What does it take to be the happiest city in the world?
What does it take to be the happiest city in the world?
The three best cities for programmers outside Silicon Valley
The three best cities for programmers outside Silicon Valley
Kowloon: a brief history of the most densely populated place on Earth
Kowloon: a brief history of the most densely populated place on Earth
The 10 largest cities in the world: What does the future hold in store for them?
The 10 largest cities in the world: What does the future hold in store for them?
Towards more walkable cities
Towards more walkable cities
Gated communities: advantages and disadvantages for cities
Gated communities: advantages and disadvantages for cities
How to stop overpopulation? 5 possible solutions to this growing issue
How to stop overpopulation? 5 possible solutions to this growing issue
Homelessness in Japan: the country with the smallest percentage of homeless people
Homelessness in Japan: the country with the smallest percentage of homeless people
Seasonal allergies: a clear example of bad urban planning
Seasonal allergies: a clear example of bad urban planning
Gender Equality: a Must-Have for Economic Growth
Gender Equality: a Must-Have for Economic Growth
Safe Food and Water for All
Safe Food and Water for All
Rio de Janeiro and Singapore: The citizen as a transforming agent
Rio de Janeiro and Singapore: The citizen as a transforming agent
What is the impact of child labor?
What is the impact of child labor?
Auckland has become the world’s most liveable city
Auckland has become the world’s most liveable city
Prediction: Future Cities Will be Filtered Through the 15-Minute Framework
Prediction: Future Cities Will be Filtered Through the 15-Minute Framework
Stanford researchers will use the Korean ‘smart city’ of Songdo as a living laboratory
Stanford researchers will use the Korean ‘smart city’ of Songdo as a living laboratory
The six best cities in the world to live and raise a family
The six best cities in the world to live and raise a family
Which are the leading smart cities in Europe?
Which are the leading smart cities in Europe?
COVID and poverty: its impact on cities
COVID and poverty: its impact on cities
Cancer and cities: risk factors and solutions for an increasingly urban society
Cancer and cities: risk factors and solutions for an increasingly urban society
Technology and equitable education: promises and obstacles of a looming revolution
Technology and equitable education: promises and obstacles of a looming revolution
How can cities help visually impaired people?
How can cities help visually impaired people?
How can cities improve the quality of life of disabled people?
How can cities improve the quality of life of disabled people?
How India wants to become the future of smart cities
How India wants to become the future of smart cities
Coworking spaces: how cities are adapting to this new work concept
Coworking spaces: how cities are adapting to this new work concept
It’s 2021. Why Are Public Spaces & Roads Still Unsafe For Women?
It’s 2021. Why Are Public Spaces & Roads Still Unsafe For Women?
5 signs that a city needs to urgently change in order to stay alive
5 signs that a city needs to urgently change in order to stay alive
These are the reasons why people abandon their city
These are the reasons why people abandon their city
Creating opportunities for a better future with the Tel-Aviv foundation
Creating opportunities for a better future with the Tel-Aviv foundation
[ui!] Urban Software Institute: Mobility for your whole life
[ui!] Urban Software Institute: Mobility for your whole life
Will there be a digital divide between smart and dumb cities?
Will there be a digital divide between smart and dumb cities?
Smart tourism destinations: the challenge of achieving a harmonious balance between industry and habitability
Smart tourism destinations: the challenge of achieving a harmonious balance between industry and habitability
Makerspaces for economic development and social cohesion
Makerspaces for economic development and social cohesion
Health, well-being and happiness should be core in urban design
Health, well-being and happiness should be core in urban design
Success story: the transformation of Singapore into a sustainable garden city
Success story: the transformation of Singapore into a sustainable garden city
Co-living or shared houses: A smart solution for cities?
Co-living or shared houses: A smart solution for cities?
Cities and maternity: how new urban planning can help with pregnancy and breastfeeding practices
Cities and maternity: how new urban planning can help with pregnancy and breastfeeding practices
Technology in schools with an impact in and out of the classrooms
Technology in schools with an impact in and out of the classrooms
Digital natives, technological illiterates?
Digital natives, technological illiterates?
Can we combat poverty with an app?
Can we combat poverty with an app?
Welcome to Vienna, the World’s best city to live in
Welcome to Vienna, the World’s best city to live in
Helsinki: opening new frontiers in digital tourism
Helsinki: opening new frontiers in digital tourism
Why we'll live in a Smart City: infographic
Why we'll live in a Smart City: infographic
Connected culture: libraries, educational programmes and idea laboratories that transform a city
Connected culture: libraries, educational programmes and idea laboratories that transform a city
Emotional Salary, a revolution for a new labour market
Emotional Salary, a revolution for a new labour market
Cities are aging with their population: challenges and solutions for an inverted pyramid
Cities are aging with their population: challenges and solutions for an inverted pyramid
Is it possible to save suburbs from themselves?
Is it possible to save suburbs from themselves?
How technology is changing the way children think and focus
How technology is changing the way children think and focus
How cities around the world are tackling poverty
How cities around the world are tackling poverty
Recommended profiles for you
Remember to activate your profile to network!
Activate profile
FG
Fernando González
ASIET
General Manager
KB
Kátia Bertol
Secretaria de Inovação e Tecnologia
Coordenadora
Giuliano Gonzales
Giuliano Gonzales
FANDES
Consultant TI
AJ
Araceli Jimenez
American Planning Association
Education Associate
PC
Priscila Coghlan
-
Architect
LV
Luis Oswaldo Velasquez lovera
Ninguna
Ninguna
BI
Bagus Ichwantoro
BSMU
Manager
Damla Kostek
Damla Kostek
Startup Grind Oslo
Community Manager
LS
Luca Sani
Prodea Group
Chief of International Business Development
Gerry De Koning
Gerry De Koning
Municipal of Almere
Information manager build environment
AH
Arie Herscovici
Western Galilee College
Lecturer
Jerome Dulin
Jerome Dulin
North Luzon Cinema Guild, Inc.
Managing Directpr
Frans-Anton Vermast
Frans-Anton Vermast
Amsterdam Smart City
Strategy advisor & international smart city ambassador
CS
Cesar Saavedra
Ez Systems Solutions LLC
CEO
Daniel Chun
Daniel Chun
Smart City Consortium
Vice President , Council Member and Chair of Research and Blueprint Committee
CA
Carmen Julia III Amundarain Ortiz
Universidad Católica Santa Rosa (UCSAR)
Docente
JE
Jiska Engelbert
Erasmus University Rotterdam
Strategic Director Centre for BOLD Cities
Sri Lestari
Sri Lestari
Nendra Lestari Sentana
Development Project
ISABELLE  FAIVRE
ISABELLE FAIVRE
LA MÉTROPOLE DE LYON
I'm in charge of marketing and territorial valorisation
GM
German Montenegro
Pontificia Universidad javeriana
professor, Researcher

Only accessible for registered users
This content is available only for registered users
TO: $$toName$$
SUBJECT: Message from $$fromName$$