This article is available also in spanish here

Fans and giant chimneys, the sustainability plasters that do not solve anything

My list

Author | Jaime RamosPollution is responsible for 8.8 million deaths worldwide each year, according to a study published in the European Heart Journal; a much higher figure than the generally accepted figures until now. It has also taken years for the authorities in the vast majority of industrialised countries to recognise that urban air pollution is a real problem for the population.This complicated process of awareness-raising encounters, ultimately, a dilemma regarding our lifestyles. Pollutants from industrial causes and transport, have led to alarming events for public health during this decade in some of the most densely populated cities, particularly in China and in India. India, unfortunately, has seven cities on the list of the ten most polluted cities in the world.

In search of rapid solutions

air pollutionSince becoming a major public health problem, the authorities in these areas have sought quick solutions to combat an environmental crisis that is jeopardising its recent escalating economic growth. They have stumbled across a very complex situation in which the ideal route would involve sacrifices within its production model, changing, for example, an energy system that depends greatly on coal.China currently produces almost two thirds of its electricity in coal-fired power plants. In 2017, two new plants were inaugurated almost every week.The Chinese energy policy began to collapse during the current decade given the rise of pollution. The country is very aware of the structural changes it is facing. However, while they are assuming the high costs involved in a rapid transition, they are choosing intermediate solutions, the long-term effectiveness of which, is somewhat dubious.

Giant chimneys and fans

The inhabitants of Xi’an, one of the most polluted cities in China, are witnessing one of these solutions which, as it gets dark, turns the silhouette of the city into that of a dystopian city. It is a giant 61-metre chimney that functions like an enormous air purifier.Those responsible for the project are proud of the effectiveness of the complex, which reduces the number of polluting PM2.5 particles by 19% and the ozone emissions. They are particularly proud of having achieved it in record time. A similar case is the new generation of waste incineration plants in China. These are fast solutions; however, the efficiency of them is dubious.

There are no shortcuts with pollution

air pollutionProjects such as the Chinese chimneys, which are humongous installations, continue to be met with scepticism within the scientific community. Experts coincide in arguing that they are treating the symptoms but not the root cause. This is what is commonly known as simply applying a plaster. The effects are partially resolved at a specific time, but not the root and underlying causes, which could get worse.The concern with this type of strategy for combating pollution, is that they are not isolated cases, they can be found in numerous places across the world and, the worst part is that they are backed by the authorities. Another serious example is in one of the most remote points of the globe, in Sibay (Russia). A cloud of smoke (that would appear to be from an old copper mine) threatened to poison the town. The controversial local solution was to install giant fans to blow it in another direction.These types of interventions do not only take place in countries with obsolete energy policies or a history of poor environmental practices. That is why examples such as the case in France, are particularly cutting, where they recently had to cancel their plans to install solar roads, once they realised that the roads crumbled as vehicles passed over them. Although there were plenty of experts that had already foreseen this when the first section was inaugurated.As illustrated, combating pollution requires measures based on a strategy that tackles the origin of the problem. Furthermore, these odd situations such as the solar roads in France or the Chinese waste incinerators, prove that not all initiatives are valid, even if they are accompanied by a halo of sustainability. Pollution is not a problem that can be solely tackled by alleviating the symptoms with experimental solutions.Images | iStock/PATTRAWUT, iStock/torwai, iStock/Roman Stavila

Related content

Recommended profiles for you

Remember to activate your profile to network!
Activate profile
FI
Fermin Ibiricu
MCP
Project Manager
JG
Jenny Guzman
Gp innovative Construction sas
Project manager
HR
Henrik Risemark
Jämtkraft AB
Strategist in Innovation unit
CS
Claudiu Salanta
Cluj County Council
Chief architect
NB
Narasimha Sai Baka
none
student
LL
Lucía López
Smart Peach
Expert in new technologies. Focused on strategies for companies to improve their working processes.
Károly Fecske
Károly Fecske
Salgotarján municipal gov
Architect manager
PK
Peter Kakucska
FOGGS
Senior Manager
IGNACIO GARCIA
IGNACIO GARCIA
MOSAIK
Director of Mosaik Urban Systems. We integrate innovative and sutainable solutions in urban areas
PA
Paola Aldaz
DDB group
Chief Innovation Officer
FD
Fernando Deco
Municipalidad
Director de Fiscalización del Mantenimiento del Alumbrado Público
OB
Ovidio Bellli
Architect
Ceo
Sagar  Choudhary
Sagar Choudhary
ABV-IIITM, Gwalior
I am a Research Scholar in our institute...
TL
Tony Liu
TAIWAN TRADE CENTER, BARCELONA
TC
TINO COLIN
AVANZIA APLICACIONES
Director de Área
YK
Yumon Kyaw
RAJU GAONKAR
RAJU GAONKAR
GOVT.
A.A.O.
Christoph Gollner
Christoph Gollner
JPI Urban Europe
Programme Manager of the PED Programme
Mayeda Jamal
Mayeda Jamal
Futureproofed
Regional Lead Nordics
CW
Carla Watine
LaSalle
I am a 1st year students in University. Doing Business administration and technologies

Only accessible for registered users
This content is available only for registered users
TO: $$toName$$
SUBJECT: Message from $$fromName$$